Wednesday afternoon, just after 4 PM. I was feeling confident after successfully managing our grocery list and actually using up last night’s leftovers. So naturally, I made the classic rookie mistake.
“Hey guys, what should we have for dinner tonight?”
My 10-year-old’s eyes lit up like Christmas morning. “Ooh! Can we have that fancy ramen from the Japanese place downtown?”
My teenager didn’t even look up from her phone. “I don’t care. Something that doesn’t suck.”
My husband called from the living room: “Whatever sounds good to you, honey!”
Perfect. So we needed fancy ramen, something non-sucky, and whatever sounds good. Easy peasy.
Spoiler alert: We had scrambled eggs and toast.
The daily dinner interrogation
Here’s what I should have learned by now: asking “what do you want for dinner?” is like opening Pandora’s box, except instead of releasing evil into the world, you’re just setting yourself up for 30 minutes of impossible negotiations.
My kids have mastered the art of requesting things that either:
- Don’t exist in our kitchen
- Take three hours to make
- Cost more than our monthly Netflix and Spotify subscriptions combined
- They claimed to hate yesterday
Last week my daughter begged for “that pasta dish from the Italian place.” When I asked which one, she said, “You know, the one that tastes good.” Super helpful.
When I finally figured out she meant carbonara and spent an hour making it from scratch, she took one bite and announced, “This doesn’t taste like the restaurant one.”
Yeah, because the restaurant one costs $24 and doesn’t come with a side of mom’s emotional breakdown.
The impossible request hall of fame
My kids have made some truly impressive dinner demands:
“Can we have sushi but like, the cooked kind, but not fish, and maybe with chicken instead?”
“I want tacos but not in a shell and without all the taco stuff.”
“Something fancy but not weird.”
And my personal favorite: “Food that tastes like food but better.”
The worst part? When I actually try to accommodate these requests, they inevitably change their minds. The kid who spent 20 minutes describing their perfect quesadilla will suddenly decide they “don’t really like cheese that much” when you set it in front of them.
The daily choice paralysis
Even when my kids give seemingly reasonable requests, it all falls apart.
Monday my son said he wanted chicken. Great! I made baked chicken with herbs. “I meant chicken nuggets.”
Tuesday my daughter requested pasta. I made spaghetti with marinara. “I wanted the kind with the white sauce. The creamy one.” “Alfredo?” “No, the OTHER white sauce.” There is no other white sauce.
By Thursday, I’d learned my lesson and stopped asking. I just announced what we were having.
“Ugh, why didn’t you ask what we wanted?” my teenager complained.
Because I value my sanity, that’s why.
What actually works
After months of dinner negotiation chaos, I figured out that kids don’t actually want unlimited choice. They want to feel heard without the pressure of making real decisions.
So I stopped asking open-ended questions and started offering limited options.
Instead of “What do you want for dinner?” I ask: “Chicken or turkey this week?” “Rice or pasta tonight?” “Should we do taco night Monday or Wednesday?”
Suddenly, everyone has opinions. Real, helpful opinions that I can actually work with.
The weekly menu board revelation
The game-changer was putting up a simple whiteboard with the week’s meals. Every Sunday, I write down what we’re having each night.
This eliminated the daily “what’s for dinner?” panic because everyone already knows. No negotiations, no last-minute scrambling, no one acting surprised that we’re having the exact meal I announced on Sunday.
My kids can still weigh in on the timing. “Can we switch taco night to Friday?” Sure. But we’re not debating whether to have tacos at all - that decision was made on Sunday when everyone was calm and thinking clearly.
The whiteboard also stops the “there’s nothing to eat” drama. Yes, there is. It’s literally written on the wall.
The safe food rule
Here’s the thing feeding experts know that I learned the hard way: every meal needs at least one thing each kid will actually eat.
Not their favorite thing, just something they won’t dramatically gag over.
When I make stir-fry, I keep some plain rice on the side. When we have salad, there’s always bread. It’s not catering to pickiness - it’s insurance against the “I guess I’ll just starve” theatrics.
My kids know the deal: I’m not making separate meals, but I’m also not trying to force anyone to eat foods they genuinely can’t handle.
When technology actually helps
I started using ChoreGami’s meal planner, and it’s been surprisingly helpful. Instead of trying to remember who currently likes what (because preferences change faster than the weather), the app tracks what everyone actually eats.
It learns that my daughter will eat broccoli but only if it’s not touching anything else. That my son likes chicken but not if it has “green stuff” on it. That my husband claims to love vegetables but somehow never finishes them.
The app suggests meals based on what my family actually consumes, not what they claim they want. It’s like having a friend who remembers all the weird food quirks so I don’t have to.
When my kids inevitably reject something, ChoreGami suggests simple modifications. “Add plain pasta on the side.” “Serve sauce separately.” “Put cheese on half.”
It’s not magic, but it eliminates a lot of the guesswork.
The reality check
Look, some weeks this system works great. Other weeks my carefully planned Thursday dinner gets derailed because someone had a bad day and suddenly can’t eat anything that’s “too orange.”
The goal isn’t perfect meals that everyone loves. The goal is getting food on the table without daily negotiations that rival international peace talks.
I’ve accepted that there will be nights when someone eats a peanut butter sandwich while everyone else has the planned meal. That’s fine. They’re fed, I’m not stressed, and we can all eat together.
Try this week
Pick one change to try:
- Stop asking “what do you want?” and start offering two specific choices
- Write out three meals on a piece of paper and let kids pick which night each happens
- Add one “safe food” to a meal you know will cause drama
The magic isn’t in getting kids to love everything. It’s in reducing the daily decision fatigue that comes with trying to please everyone all the time.
Once you’ve figured out what your family will actually eat, you might enjoy our multi-diet meal planning series for tips on cooking efficiently, shopping smart, and managing leftovers when everyone has different dietary needs.
What’s your biggest dinner negotiation disaster? Have you fallen into the “what do you want” trap? We’d love to hear your stories! Email us at hello@choregami.com or tag us on Instagram @choregami!
Ready to stop playing dinner guessing games? ChoreGami’s meal planning features help families track real preferences and create systems that actually work.
Comments (0)
Be the first to leave a comment!
Leave a Comment